Curiosities

Jack the Ripper and a Kłodawa-born barber: What the DNA evidence really shows

Once again, the claim resurfaces that Jack the Ripper was Aaron Kosminski, a barber born in Kłodawa. It rests on DNA testing of a shawl, but experts have for years questioned its evidential value.

Where the DNA theory comes from

Aaron Kosminski (also spelled Kośmiński in Polish sources) was born in 1865 in Kłodawa in the Congress Kingdom and died in 1919. He emigrated to England around 1881. From 1891 he was held in psychiatric institutions. He appears on lists of suspects from the Victorian-era investigation, but was never formally charged.

The claim of his guilt rests on a shawl which, according to supporters of the theory, was found beside the body of Catherine Eddowes, one of the victims from 1888. In 2014, author Russell Edwards wrote in the book “Naming Jack the Ripper” that DNA tests point to Kosminski. A further analysis, involving scientists from Liverpool and Leeds, was published in the “Journal of Forensic Sciences”. Its authors wrote that they were describing the only surviving physical evidence linked to these crimes.

What was actually compared

Mitochondrial DNA, which is inherited from the mother, was examined. It was compared with samples from living relatives of the victim and the suspect. Such an analysis is not a unique identifier like nuclear DNA. The signature attributed to Kosminski (T1a1) was described as a relatively common subtype.

Why there are doubts

Critics question whether the shawl was really found at Eddowes’s body. They also point to the possibility that the material was contaminated over the years. They note that full genetic data has not been published, which makes independent verification difficult. Some researchers also believe that Kosminski is a poor match for the descriptions of the perpetrator given by witnesses.

The case therefore remains open. At least five women were killed by the Whitechapel killer, and his identity has never been officially established. There is no statement on the matter from the Polish prosecutor’s office or police, because the crimes were committed in London in the 19th century.

Dorota Lune

Dorota Lune, redaktorka serwisu DigitalNexus.pl. Zajmuje się tematyką show-biznesową, bieżącymi informacjami jak i ciekawostkami ze świata. Ukończyła dziennikarstwo na UPJPII w Krakowie. Wcześniej pracowała w branży turystycznej. W wolnych chwilach lubi podróżować i czytać książki.