Poland

The Property Commission and Church Restitutions: What Has Been Established About Abuses

The Property Commission, which returned properties seized under communist rule to the Catholic Church, is still associated with scandals and prosecutors’ investigations. We recall what documents and findings of law enforcement bodies say about its activities.

What the Property Commission was

The commission operated on the basis of Article 62 of the act of 17 May 1989 on the relationship between the State and the Catholic Church. According to the Ministry of Interior and Administration (MSWiA)’s replies to parliamentary interpellations, it was a government-Church body operating in a mediation and amicable settlement mode. It was neither a public administration body nor a court. It was headed by two co-chairs: one was appointed by the minister of internal affairs, the other by the secretary of the Polish Episcopal Conference.

The commission considered claims concerning property taken over by the state during the communist period. It could approve settlements or rule on the return of property, the allocation of substitute property, or compensation.

Scale of restitutions

According to the commission’s activity report for 1989–2011, cited in the ministry’s reply to interpellation no. 9347, 3,063 applications were submitted within the statutory deadline. Over 90 percent of proceedings were concluded, and 666 of them ended with the application being rejected, dismissed or discontinued. According to the MSWiA report, the commission transferred properties with a total area of over 65,000 hectares to Church legal entities.

Investigations and charges

Irregularities were examined by, among others, the Central Anticorruption Bureau (CBA) and prosecutors. The CBA forwarded notifications to prosecutors concerning specific decisions. The prosecutor’s office in Gliwice conducted proceedings for falsifying documents, including in the matter of valuations of land transferred to a parish in Jastrzębie-Zdrój. The District Prosecutor’s Office in Warsaw charged seven people in connection with the transfer of a plot in the capital to the Order of St. Elizabeth Sisters.

In the Kraków case, prosecutors accused members of the commission and persons linked to it of, among other things, acting to the detriment of the State Treasury and certifying untruths. According to the indictment, in one instance the State Treasury was to have lost nearly PLN 28 million because the valuation report was unreliable. The accused did not admit guilt. They are presumed innocent, and verdicts in individual cases should be checked in court rulings.

Dissolution of the commission

The commission was abolished by the act of 16 December 2010. It ceased to exist on 1 March 2011, and its work was to be completed by 28 February 2011. The documentation was handed over to the minister responsible for religious affairs. Participants in proceedings in which no decision had been agreed could pursue their claims in court within six months.

Dorota Lune

Dorota Lune, redaktorka serwisu DigitalNexus.pl. Zajmuje się tematyką show-biznesową, bieżącymi informacjami jak i ciekawostkami ze świata. Ukończyła dziennikarstwo na UPJPII w Krakowie. Wcześniej pracowała w branży turystycznej. W wolnych chwilach lubi podróżować i czytać książki.