The Military District Court in Warsaw on Friday, 20 November, overturned the non-final verdict acquitting Private Karol S., charged with exceeding his powers after firing shots at the Belarus border. The case returns to the first-instance court.
Prosecution appeal upheld
The appellate court fully upheld the appeal by the District Prosecutor’s Office in Warsaw against the verdict of the Military Garrison Court in Lublin. As the prosecution announced on Friday, the soldier, by firing shots, “endangered other soldiers, Border Guard officers and migrants”. The acquittal was issued at the end of May and was not final.
What the appellate court found
According to the reasoning announced by Judge Col. Paweł Więcek, Private Karol S. fired 12 warning shots toward a group of migrants illegally crossing the border. At least three of them exposed them to a direct risk of loss of life or serious bodily harm. The same risk applied to two Border Guard officers and two soldiers intervening at the time. In the court’s view, the accused’s conduct met the elements of the offence he was charged with.
The ruling is not a decision on guilt – the court overturned the acquittal and referred the case for re-examination.
The March 2024 incident
The shots were fired on 25 March 2024 near Dubicze Cerkiewne. According to the indictment, the soldier, running at a distance of about 210 to about 164 metres from the group, took a shooting stance and fired 12 shots from his service weapon along the border road toward migrants, Border Guard officers and soldiers. Investigators established that three bullets ricocheted off a concrete pole, the ground and coils of barbed wire, while the remaining nine passed by the group. The migrants were reportedly retreating to the Belarusian side and throwing branches and stones at the uniformed personnel, who were using tear gas.
The Military Garrison Court had earlier found that the soldier did not exceed his powers and that the shots were not aimed at any person. The court also assessed that the prosecution’s position was unfounded.
What happens next
After the ruling was announced, the defence lawyers said they would consider further steps once they receive the written reasoning. A complaint to the Supreme Court is available against a verdict overturning an acquittal. If no complaint is filed or it is not upheld, the trial will restart before the military garrison court.
The case concerns the situation at the border, which we also covered in the context of the extension of the suspension of the right to asylum.




